3 Top Catering Companies in New Paltz, NY — Which One Fits Your Event?

From farm-to-table weddings to corporate lunches, here's how the area's best caterers stack up.

Whether you're planning a wedding at Mohonk, a corporate retreat, or a milestone birthday, New Paltz has no shortage of talented caterers — but each brings a different strength to the table. Here's a look at three of the most acclaimed and how they compare.

Main Course Catering + Events

Website: maincoursecatering.com

Main Course is the longest-running caterer in the area, voted Best in the Hudson Valley for over two decades. Located right on Main Street, they offer full-service catering for weddings, corporate events, and private parties — plus a retail marketplace for everyday orders. Their versatility is their edge: they handle everything from a 300-person seated dinner to a casual drop-off lunch for 15.

Best for: Corporate clients, casual gatherings, and couples who want an all-in-one caterer with a retail ordering option.

Bridge Creek Catering

Website: bridgecreekcatering.com

Based at 30 Jenkinstown Road, Bridge Creek is the wedding-catering specialist. They've earned The Knot's Best of Weddings award 12 years running (2012–2023) and the WeddingWire Couples' Choice Award six times. Their menus are deeply customizable, and their team is known for seamless day-of coordination at Hudson Valley venues.

Best for: Couples planning a wedding or rehearsal dinner who want a caterer with a proven, award-winning wedding track record.

Agnes Devereux Catering

Website: agnesdevereuxcatering.com

Agnes Devereux is the farm-to-table choice. A former chef and owner of New Paltz's beloved Village Tearoom, she's earned Chronogram Magazine's Best Caterer in the Hudson Valley. Menus are built around local, seasonal ingredients sourced from neighboring farms — and her signature honey bee wedding cake is legendary.

Best for: Eco-conscious couples and hosts who prioritize locally sourced, artisan food and handmade desserts.

Quick Comparison

Feature	Main Course	Bridge Creek	Agnes Devereux
Established	24+ years	12+ award years	Tearoom heritage
Specialty	Full-service versatility	Custom weddings	Farm-to-table + cakes
Corporate	✓ Strong	Limited	Occasional
Location	175 Main St, New Paltz	30 Jenkinstown Rd, New Paltz	18 Hollow Rd, Staatsburg
Price range	$$$	$$$$	$$$$

No matter which you choose, you're getting Hudson Valley talent at its finest. Match the caterer to your event type and your priorities — versatility, wedding expertise, or farm-fresh sourcing — and you can't go wrong.