Tommy I's: The Chef Who Left a 300-Year-Old Manor House to Cook What He Actually Loves |
New Paltz's newest restaurant proves the best opening act isn't on the main stage — it's on the corner of Main and Huguenot, where Chef Tommy Ingoglia is finally cooking free |
If you've eaten at the Bistro at Hasbrouck House in Newburgh — the fine-dining gem tucked inside one of the oldest stone houses in America — then you know Chef Tommy Ingoglia's food. Elegant. Precise. Beautiful on the plate. But here's the thing about cooking inside a historic manor house: the building gets a vote in every menu decision. After years of pulling off that balancing act, Tommy walked away from the job everyone wanted and opened Tommy I's in January 2026 on his own terms.
The Short Version
Tommy I's sits in the old Dutch tavern space at 215 Main Street — a spot that had been mostly dormant for years. The walls got a refresh, the energy got rewired, and suddenly New Paltz has a place that feels like it belongs in Brooklyn but uses mostly hyper-local ingredients. The menu bounces between Asian and Latin without apology: crispy rice with tuna tartare, crab Rangoon, pork tacos, and a lobster mac and cheese finished with black truffle that has people posting on Instagram the second it hits the table.
The Backstory, Told in One Dish
Order the crab Rangoon. It's a cream-cheese-filled wonton — the most retro, diner-adjacent thing you could possibly put on a menu. Except Tommy's version is pan-seared, served on a bright yellow plate, dotted with pickled chili and fried garlic, and it comes with a little ramekin of sauce that makes the whole thing sing. That's the whole restaurant in one bite: a reference point from a 1980s TGI Fridays menu, executed with the kind of technique that only someone who spent years in a stone manor house would have.
What to Know Before You Go
- Location: 215 Main Street, New Paltz (corner of Huguenot and Main) - Vibe: Small plates, big cocktails, a room that feels lived-in but intentional - Hours: Check Instagram @tommyis.ny for current schedule — it's new - Reservations: Recommended on weekends; walk-ins welcome on weeknights
Why This Matters for New Paltz
The village has had plenty of great restaurants. What it hasn't had, until now, is a chef-driven cocktail-and-small-plates spot in the middle of the walkable downtown core — the kind of place where you can drop in solo for a glass of something interesting and a plate of something strange, or bring a group of six and have the night of your life. Tommy I's is that place. |
10 Comments
Join the conversation
Quick tip for anyone going, street parking on Huguenot fills up fast on weekends. There's a lot behind the CVS that most people forget about. Worth knowing before you circle for 20 minutes like I did.
localfoodie845Oh thank you for this. We learned that lesson the hard way at Mahoney's on a Saturday night and I was not doing it again. Saving this comment for when we go next month.
Had Tommy's food at Hasbrouck House a few years back and it was one of the best meals I've had in the region. The fact that he's doing crab Rangoon now is honestly hilarious in the best possible way. That man could make a fish stick taste like a Michelin meal.
Tom B.Ha, the fish stick comment is so accurate. I worked a block from Hasbrouck House for two years and treated myself to his tasting menu once. Still think about it. Very curious what he does with the more casual format.
I appreciate the talent but Asian-Latin fusion in a 200 year old Dutch tavern in the Hudson Valley does feel a little all over the place to me. Hope the execution holds up once the hype dies down. Will reserve judgment until I actually get a table.
Margot FleischerI get the skepticism but honestly that mashup kind of fits New Paltz? The town itself is a little all over the place and it works. The execution is the real question though, agree on that.
That Dutch tavern space sat empty for so long it was kind of depressing to walk past. Really glad someone finally did something interesting with it. Will try to get in on a weeknight since I heard weekends are already packed.
sierra_npSame, I walked past that space probably twice a week and it just felt like wasted potential every time. Weeknights are the move for sure, my friend went on a Tuesday and got right in.
Went last Friday with my wife and the lobster mac was absolutely insane. We sat there for like ten minutes just staring at it before we ate it. The truffle smell alone is worth the trip. New Paltz needed something like this badly.
Dave KowalskiThe truffle smell is no joke. We were at the table next to you probably, everyone kept looking over when it came out. Definitely earned those ten minutes of just staring at it.